Over the past few decades, the value of college degrees has declined significantly. With more people graduating from college than ever before, the market has become saturated with degree holders. This oversupply of graduates combined with rising tuition costs has led many to question the return on investment of higher education.

The Degree Bubble

There is growing evidence that we are in the midst of a “degree bubble” similar to the housing bubble that led to the 2008 financial crisis. As more Americans have sought college degrees, both public and private universities have raised tuition rates exponentially, leading to a trillion dollar student debt crisis. This has inflated the perceived value of degrees beyond actual market value. Much like the housing market in 2008, the degree bubble appears likely to burst in the coming years.

Degree Inflation

Degree inflation refers to the devaluation of academic credentials due to supply and demand imbalances in the higher education system. Over the past three decades, the number of four-year degrees conferred in the US has risen over 200% while demand has failed to keep pace. This means that bachelor’s degrees are now so commonplace that they no longer differentiate candidates in the job market the way they once did.

In many entry level positions, college graduates are now competing with those who hold master’s degrees, further driving the need for advanced credentials. Even as the costs of education skyrocket, the market value of academic credentials continues to decline. This creates a frustrating paradox for recent graduates struggling to get a return on their educational investment.

Automation and Offshoring

Two of the biggest threats to the value of degrees in today’s economy are automation and offshoring. As technology continues to advance, more and more jobs are becoming automated. Both blue collar and increasingly white collar professions are losing roles to robots, software, and artificial intelligence.

By one estimate, 47% of US jobs are at high risk of automation over the next decade or two. As automation accelerates, demand for college-educated workers could decline significantly across various industries.

In addition, globalization has allowed companies to offshore previously safe office jobs to countries with lower labor costs. Everything from computer programming to financial analysis and medical diagnostic work can now be outsourced. As offshoring ramps up in scale, many lucrative careers once considered safe with a degree are no longer secure.

Alternatives to Degrees Gain Steam

Faced with exorbitant higher education costs and uncertain outcomes, many are now skipping college degrees altogether or seeking alternative pathways into promising careers. High-profile business leaders like Elon Musk, Steve Jobs, and Bill Gates have questioned the value of college degrees for those seeking jobs in tech.

Bootcamps, certifications, apprenticeships, and other career accelerators are gaining popularity with both employers and students as cheaper, faster alternatives. Trade schools and vocational programs also continue to provide a direct path to well-paying jobs without the cost and time investment of a traditional four-year degree.

As these alternatives proliferate, bachelor’s degrees will face mounting pressure to demonstrate value in a crowded, competitive job market. Those without clear return on investment value propositions will suffer declining demand in the coming decades.

Actionable Tips

Consider Alternatives

With the value of degrees declining, it’s wise to at least consider alternative pathways beyond the “go to college” conveyor belt. Lower cost certifications, apprenticeships, or bootcamps may offer similar income trajectories in certain fields without the debt or time commitment of a bachelor’s degree. Analyze the ROI of various options within your field of interest.

Specialize Early

Certain specialized degrees in high demand fields like computer science, engineering, data analytics, healthcare, and advanced manufacturing can still provide good returns. Research starting and mid-career salaries for specialized programs to find viable options. The key is choosing a program with hard skills that industry needs rather than general degrees that face automation threats.

Minimize Debt

If pursuing a four-year degree, minimize debt by exploring in-state public school options, commuting from home, or working through school. Draw out degree timelines if needed to accommodate work schedules and save on expenses. Starting post-grad life with minimal debt offers more flexibility and options.

Develop Hard & Soft Skills

Degrees checks boxes, but skills get jobs. Make sure to develop in-demand hard skills within your field of study via internships, certifications, online courses, and student projects. Soft skills like communication, emotional intelligence, critical thinking, and project management are also key. Tie all skills to career goals.

Network Early & Often

Degrees open doors but networks get you in the room. Treat education as an opportunity to build professional relationships through professors, internships, clubs, and alumni. Skillfully leveraging these networks is essential for surfacing key opportunities.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why are so many graduates struggling to find jobs?

With degree inflation and automation threatening many traditional career paths, the college-to-career conveyor belt is breaking down. Graduates face more competition for quality jobs both from degree holders and non-degree holders with experience. Developing in-demand skills and professional networks provide an advantage.

Are any degrees still worth the investment?

Degrees with clear ROI value propositions in high-growth fields are still worth the cost and time investment. Examples include computer science, engineering, data science, select healthcare occupations, skilled trades, and technical services with automation resistance. Research starting salaries and growth outlooks when selecting degree programs.

What majors are least valuable in today’s economy?

Majors with poorest returns on investment include most general liberal arts and social sciences like sociology, political science, anthropology, and history. These develop valued soft skills but offer few hard skills applicable in today’s workplace. Without specialized expertise or networks, graduates struggle to surface opportunities.

Should my kids skip college?

College may still make sense for students with clear career goals in high-demand, high-paying fields better served by traditional degree pathways. However, considering alternative pathways makes sense based on student interests and economic realities. Apprenticeships and technical training offer promising options without the cost of college.

What are the best alternatives I can explore?

The best alternatives vary by industry and interests but may include bootcamps, vocational/trade schools, professional certifications, apprenticeships, on the job training, self-directed learning, and entrepreneurship. All offer cheaper, faster ways to develop career-relevant skills without time and debt burdens of traditional college.

Learn more